Government Accused of Discriminating Against Expats in Wildfire Aid Law
The Portuguese government is facing a formal challenge over new legislation that provides financial aid for the reconstruction of homes destroyed by wildfires. The Council of Portuguese Communities (CCP) has submitted a letter to Prime Minister Luís Montenegro, asserting that the new law is discriminatory for excluding Portuguese citizens who live abroad.
The specific detail of the new regulation at the center of the dispute is a clause that restricts eligibility for aid to properties that serve as the “residência principal e habitual do agregado familiar” (the main and habitual residence of the household). This effectively disqualifies a vast number of Portuguese emigrants who own second homes in Portugal, which are often ancestral family properties or holiday homes.
The implementation timeline for this aid is critical as communities recover from recent fires, but the CCP is demanding an urgent revision of the law. The council argues that the legislation fails to recognize the deep connection emigrants maintain with Portugal through these properties. “A casa em Portugal representa, para o emigrante, um vínculo material e emocional insubstituível,” the letter states, highlighting the personal and financial sacrifices often made to maintain these homes.
The primary group affected by this legislation is the large Portuguese diaspora. The CCP and other political figures, such as Vitor Silva, a socialist representative for emigrants, argue that these citizens are being treated as second-class despite contributing significantly to the economy through taxes and remittances. The compliance requirement of being a full-time resident is seen as an unfair barrier.
There are potential penalties for non-compliance with other aspects of property ownership, but in this case, the consequence is a complete lack of access to state support following a natural disaster. The industry reaction, particularly from groups representing emigrants, has been one of strong opposition. The CCP has called the law a violation of constitutional principles of equality.
Legal professionals are interpreting the new rules as potentially unconstitutional. The CCP’s letter explicitly references articles of the Portuguese Constitution related to equality and the rights of non-resident citizens, suggesting a legal challenge may be forthcoming. The government’s rationale for the clause has not been fully articulated, but it is seen by opponents as a cost-saving measure that unfairly targets non-residents.
This legislative issue could lead to related regulations being scrutinized for similar discriminatory clauses. The CCP has requested that the government not only amend the current law but also ensure all future disaster relief mechanisms are designed to be inclusive of all Portuguese citizens, regardless of their place of residence. Resources for understanding compliance with property laws are available, but this issue centers on access to state aid, not regulatory adherence.
Navigate Portuguese property regulations with expert guidance at realestate-lisbon.com.
