Setúbal Peninsula Maternity Services Collapse, Exposing Deep SNS Vulnerabilities
The Ministry of Health confirmed on Saturday the sudden and complete closure of all obstetrics and gynecology emergency departments across the Setúbal Peninsula, a region serving over 800,000 residents south of Lisbon. The announcement, which cited an acute shortage of doctors to cover weekend shifts, forced the redirection of all pregnant women to hospitals in Lisbon, triggering widespread criticism and exposing the fragility of the National Health Service (SNS) in the area. The primary facility affected, Garcia de Orta Hospital (HGO) in Almada, was the sole hospital designated to provide these services over the weekend but was unable to secure the necessary medical staff. Services only resumed on Monday morning, September 15, after a weekend of disruption.
This service collapse directly contradicts recent assurances from Health Minister Ana Paula Martins, who had publicly stated that a contingency plan was in place to ensure at least one maternity unit would always remain operational on the peninsula. The failure to uphold this promise has led to a firestorm of criticism from municipal leaders, medical associations, and political parties. Inês de Medeiros, the mayor of Almada, voiced her deep concern, stating, “It is obvious that we view this situation with increasing concern because, contrary to what has been forcefully announced, there is no plan that is actually working.” She lamented the government's decision to abandon a previous strategy developed by the former SNS executive board, which she claimed offered more predictability and a structured approach to staffing shortages.
Minister Ana Paula Martins publicly acknowledged the situation as “very worrying.” In her statements to the press, she attributed the crisis to the unavailability of a pool of more than 20 freelance doctors who are regularly contracted to fill gaps in hospital shifts. “We have, naturally, a bolsa of doctors that work with our teams... and this bolsa of more than 20 professionals did not have availability to guarantee at least one urgency open,” she explained. The minister stressed that these doctors are not bound by contract to the SNS, stating, “They work really at the task,” and conceded that this heavy reliance on outsourced labor represents a significant, ongoing vulnerability for the health service's human resources.
Need Expert Guidance?
Get personalized insights from verified real estate professionals, lawyers, architects, and more.
The incident has drawn a sharp response from the Portuguese Medical Association (OM), whose president, Carlos Cortes, pointed to the “permanent failures” of the Ministry of Health and the SNS Executive Directorate to adequately address the well-known staffing difficulties on the Setúbal Peninsula. He argued that a robust “plan of reserve, a redundancy” should have been in place for such a critical service area. The National Federation of Doctors (FNAM) went further, with its president, Joana Bordalo e Sá, accusing the government of “pure electoral propaganda” and creating “inequality” by attempting to recruit a handful of private-sector doctors with special contracts, a measure she deemed insufficient to solve the systemic staffing deficit. “We have obstetrics collapsing,” she warned, listing several other hospitals across the country facing similar shortages.
The political fallout has been swift, with the Livre party announcing its intention to summon Minister Martins to parliament for questioning. Livre’s spokesperson, Rui Tavares, criticized the government for what he described as “rhetoric” over “solutions,” highlighting the lack of progress on the long-awaited Seixal Hospital, which is widely seen as the necessary long-term solution for the region's healthcare capacity issues. According to Tavares, the party has received numerous reports from citizens in the Setúbal district who describe the local healthcare situation as “becoming very serious indeed.” The Health Minister was scheduled to meet with the administrations of the three Local Health Units on the peninsula on Monday afternoon to address the crisis.
The closure of essential medical services like maternity wards raises significant questions about the adequacy of public infrastructure and the quality of life for residents on the Setúbal Peninsula. The event underscores the challenges the SNS faces in retaining medical professionals and ensuring consistent care outside the capital's central core. For a region that is increasingly popular for its residential appeal, the reliability of its healthcare system remains a critical and unresolved issue. Explore health-conscious communities and properties at realestate-lisbon.com.